Award: OCE-0927255

Award Title: Ocean acidification in a California upwelling zone: A sentinel site for impacts on open-coast and estuarine foundation species
Funding Source: NSF Division of Ocean Sciences (NSF OCE)
Program Manager: David L. Garrison

Outcomes Report

NSF AWARD OCE-0927255 OCEAN ACIDIFICATION IN A CALIFORNIA UPWELLING ZONE: A SENTINEL SITE FOR IMPACTS ON OPEN-COAST AND ESTUARINE FOUNDATION SPECIES PROJECT OUTCOMES The oceans have absorbed about one third of the carbon dioxide (CO2) produced by humans since the early 1800Æs. This uptake of CO2 changes the chemistry of seawater by making it more acidic, which in turn can make it more difficult for organisms to produce their shells and skeletons and maintain the proper chemical balance within their tissues. Along the west coast of the U.S., prevailing winds blow in such a way as to push surface waters offshore. In response, deeper waters "upwell" to replace them. These deeper waters are naturally high in carbon dioxide. As a consequence, conditions along the California, Oregon, and Washington coasts intrinsically experience more acidic seawater, onto which the human-derived effects of CO2 are then layered. These areas may therefore provide early insight into how marine systems in general will respond to elevated seawater CO2. This project addressed impacts of ocean acidification on several critical species that live along the coast of California. In particular, it explored how elevated seawater CO2 influences growth and survival of Olympia oysters and California mussels, focusing on the vulnerable microscopic larval stages of these creatures which live for a time in the plankton. Resultant research revealed declines in the sizes of the shells of larval mussels, dramatic reductions in their tissue mass, and impaired shell strength. In oyster larvae, ocean acidification causes decreases in growth. Such decreases also become magnified once the planktonic larvae settle on the seafloor and become juveniles. This latter effect is analogous to how environmental conditions in early human life can stunt growth and impair health years later. Accompanying tests showed that impacts of remarkably brief exposures of oysters to ocean acidification persist for months under natural field conditions, and do not attenuate over time even in benign habitats. Similarly, impacts are not fully overcome by giving oysters extra food. Additional experiments conducted as part of the project also demonstrate effects of elevated seawater CO2 on limpets, on predator-prey interactions between oysters and the snails that consume them, on growth of sea urchin larvae, and on respiration rates of larval crabs. In the case of urchin larvae, there are hints that sufficient genetic differences exist among populations to allow certain strains to differentially succeed in the face of elevated seawater CO2. Such strains may have the potential to offset population declines. Whether other species might have the capacity to respond similarly remains unclear. The project contributed to the advancement of several graduate students and postdoctoral researchers who were supported by the grant, led to the development of an academic-industry partnership with a local oyster grower, and was covered by the popular media in multiple articles, radio broadcasts, and videos. Last Modified: 09/11/2013 Submitted by: Brian P Gaylord
DatasetLatest Version DateCurrent State
Temperature, pH, and salinity collected by SAMI sensors at the Bodega Marine Lab mooring in the nearshore surface waters off the central California coast from 2011-2012 (BOAR and OMEGAS-MaS projects)2015-03-31Final with updates expected
pCO2 collected by SAMI-CO2 sensors from Bodega Marine Laboratory Mooring in the nearshore surface waters off the central California coast from 2011-2012 (BOAR project)2013-10-22Final with updates expected
Water quality (including salinity, temperature, pH, O2, chl, DIC, DOC) time series from a mooring and time-series transect in Tomales Bay, Central California Coast from 2008-2011 (BOAR project)2012-10-12Final with updates expected
Juvenile growth of Olympia oysters outplanted to the field in Tomales Bay after being reared as larvae in the lab at Bodega Marine Lab in September 20102016-09-27Final no updates expected
Juvenile survival of Olympia oysters outplanted to the field in Tomales Bay after being reared as larvae in the lab at Bodega Marina lab in September 20102016-09-09Final no updates expected
Percent settlement (metamorphosis) of Olympia oysters exposed to ocean acidification in the laboratory at Bodega Marine Lab in September 20102016-09-09Final no updates expected
Size at settlement of Olympia oysters exposed to ocean acidification in the laboratory at lab Bodega Marine in September 20102016-09-09Final no updates expected
Water chemistry during larval rearing experiments concerning persistent effects of ocean acidification on larval and juvenile Olympia oysters conducted at Bodega Marine Laboratory in September 20102016-09-27Final no updates expected
Juvenile growth post-settlement from experimental study of carryover effects of ocean acidification on larval and juvenile Olympia oysters; conducted at Bodega Marine Lab in July-Sept 20092016-09-13Final no updates expected
Juvenile growth post-settlement under four larval-to-juvenile ocean acidification transitions in the laboratory; conducted at Bodega Marine Lab in July-Sept 20092016-09-16Final no updates expected
Oyster larval growth at day 9 post-release under ocean acidification in the laboratory; experiments conducted at Bodega Marine Laboratory2016-09-16Final no updates expected
Effects of food on body condition of larval oysters under different levels of ocean acidification; experiments conducted at Bodega Marine Laboratory (BML), UC Davis in June 20112016-09-19Final no updates expected
Effects of food on growth of larval Olympia oysters under different levels of ocean acidification; experiments conducted at Bodega Marine Laboratory (BML), UC Davis in June 20112016-09-19Final no updates expected
Effects of food on percent metamorphosis of settling Olympia oysters under different levels of ocean acidification; experiments conducted at Bodega Marine Laboratory, UC Davis in June 20112016-09-19Final no updates expected
Results of laboratory study examining effects of elevated concentrations of seawater carbon dioxide and altered salinity on rates of oxygen utilization by larval porcelain crabs (Petrolisthes cinctipes)2016-09-28Final no updates expected
Results of laboratory study examining effects of elevated concentrations of seawater carbon dioxide and altered salinity on rates of oxygen utilization by larval porcelain crabs (Petrolisthes cinctipes)2016-09-28Final no updates expected
Results of laboratory study examining effects of elevated concentrations of seawater carbon dioxide and altered salinity on rates of oxygen utilization by larval porcelain crabs (Petrolisthes cinctipes)2016-09-29Final no updates expected
Results of laboratory study examining effects of elevated concentrations of seawater carbon dioxide and altered salinity on rates of oxygen utilization by larval porcelain crabs (Petrolisthes cinctipes)2016-09-29Final no updates expected

Award Home Page

NSF Research Results Report


People

Principal Investigator: Brian P. Gaylord (University of California-Davis)

Co-Principal Investigator: Ann Russell

Co-Principal Investigator: Eric D Sanford

Co-Principal Investigator: Tessa M Hill